Best Toyota Highlander Car Insurance 2024 (Top 10 Companies Ranked)

For the best Toyota Highlander car insurance, Geico stands out with its exceptional customer service and broad coverage options. Erie and USAA are also top choices. Erie is recognized for its attractive bundling discounts, which can lead to significant savings.

While USAA is distinguished by its superior claims handling and specialized benefits for military families, offering valuable support to those who qualify.

Our Top 10 Company Picks: Best Toyota Highlander Car Insurance

These leading providers each bring unique strengths, ensuring you receive reliable and personalized insurance solutions for your Toyota Highlander. For a comprehensive analysis, refer to our detailed guide titled “How do you find competitive car insurance rates?”

Enter your ZIP code above into our free comparison tool to see how much car insurance costs in your area.

Free Car Insurance Comparison

Enter your ZIP code below to view companies that have cheap car insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

#1 – Geico: Top Overall Pick

Pros

• Competitive Premiums: Discover our Geico car insurance review to see why it offers some of the most affordable rates for budget-conscious Toyota Highlander owners.
• Valuable Discounts: Geico provides a variety of discounts, including those for safe driving and bundling, which can lower the cost of insurance for Toyota Highlander drivers.
• Advanced Digital Tools: Geico’s user-friendly mobile app and website streamline policy management and claims processing, enhancing convenience for Toyota Highlander owners.

Cons

• Variable Customer Service: Geico’s customer service can be inconsistent, which may lead to slower response times or less personalized support for Toyota Highlander drivers.
• Limited Specialized Coverage: Geico may not offer as many specialized coverage options, which could be a drawback for Toyota Highlander drivers needing specific types of protection.

#2 – Erie: Best for Customer Service

Pros

• Broad Coverage Options: Erie provides a wide range of coverage options tailored for Toyota Highlander drivers, ensuring comprehensive protection for various driving scenarios.
• High Customer Satisfaction: Based on our Erie car insurance review, you’ll find that the company’s excellent customer service through local agents benefits Toyota Highlander owners.
• Appealing Discount Programs: Erie offers discount programs for bundling multiple policies, which can help reduce insurance premiums for Toyota Highlander drivers.

Cons

• Limited Geographic Availability: Erie’s insurance services are not available in all states, which may restrict access for some Toyota Highlander owners based on their location.
• Potentially Higher Premiums: Insurance costs with Erie might be higher compared to other insurers, affecting affordability for Toyota Highlander drivers.

#3 – USAA: Best for Military Benefits

Pros

• Exceptional Military Benefits: USAA offers outstanding insurance benefits specifically for military members, including competitive rates and excellent claims handling for Toyota Highlander owners.
• Top-Rated Customer Service: USAA consistently receives high ratings for customer satisfaction, providing reliable support to military families with Toyota Highlanders.
• Significant Discounts: With our USAA car insurance review, learn how generous discounts for safe driving and multiple vehicles can lower premiums for Toyota Highlander drivers.

Cons

• Eligibility Restrictions: USAA’s services are exclusive to military members and their families, potentially excluding many Toyota Highlander owners who do not meet these criteria.
• Fluctuating Premium Rates: Premiums with USAA can vary based on location and driving history, which might result in inconsistent rates for Toyota Highlander insurance.

Free Car Insurance Comparison

Enter your ZIP code below to view companies that have cheap car insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

#4 – State Farm: Best for Nationwide Presence

Pros

• Widespread Availability: View our State Farm car insurance review to discover how its nationwide coverage ensures accessibility for Toyota Highlander owners.
• Diverse Discounts: State Farm offers various discounts, including those for safe driving and policy bundling, which can make insurance more affordable for Toyota Highlander drivers.
• Local Agent Support: An extensive network of local agents provides personalized service and tailored insurance solutions for Toyota Highlander owners.

Cons

• Higher Premiums for Some Drivers: Toyota Highlander drivers with a history of claims or less-than-perfect driving records might face higher premiums with State Farm.
• Slow Claims Processing: Some customers report slower claims processing times, which could delay issue resolution for Toyota Highlander owners.

#5 – Travelers: Best for Comprehensive Coverage

Pros

• Customizable Policies: Discover our Travelers car insurance review to see how it offers flexible policies tailored to the needs of Toyota Highlander drivers.
• Discount Opportunities: Multiple discount options, including those for safe driving and bundling policies, can help reduce overall insurance costs for Toyota Highlander owners.
• Effective Digital Tools: Travelers’ user-friendly app and website facilitate easy management of policies and claims, enhancing convenience for Toyota Highlander drivers.

Cons

• Inconsistent Customer Service: Travelers has received mixed feedback regarding customer service, with some Toyota Highlander owners experiencing delays and less responsive support.
• Variable Premium Rates: Rates with Travelers can be higher for drivers with traffic violations or prior claims, potentially impacting affordability for Toyota Highlander insurance.

#6 – Allstate: Best for Extensive Discounts

Pros

• Strong Financial Stability: See our Allstate car insurance review to learn about its robust financial position and how it ensures reliable support for Toyota Highlander insurance.
• Wide Range of Discounts: Numerous discounts and a rewards program for safe driving and bundling can lower insurance premiums for Toyota Highlander owners.
• Local Agent Network: Allstate’s extensive network of local agents provides accessible and personalized service, benefiting Toyota Highlander drivers.

Cons

• Higher Premiums Compared to Competitors: Toyota Highlander drivers might find Allstate’s premiums to be higher than those of some other insurance providers, impacting overall affordability.
• Mixed Claims Experience: Customer feedback on the claims process can vary, with some reporting less satisfactory experiences.

Free Car Insurance Comparison

Enter your ZIP code below to view companies that have cheap car insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

#7 – Farmers: Best for Customizable Policies

Pros

• Comprehensive Coverage Options: Farmers offers a broad selection of coverage options that can be customized to fit the needs of Toyota Highlander drivers, ensuring well-rounded protection.
• Discounts for Savings: Multiple discounts for bundling policies and maintaining a good driving record can help reduce insurance costs for Toyota Highlander owners.
• Personalized Service: Explore our Farmers car insurance review to find out how its network of local agents provides tailored support for Toyota Highlander drivers.

Cons

• Higher Premium Costs: Insurance premiums with Farmers may be higher, particularly for Toyota Highlander drivers with a history of claims or higher risk profiles.
• Service Variability: Customer service experiences can vary, with some reports of inconsistent service.

#8 – Nationwide: Best for Claim Satisfaction

Pros

• Variety of Coverage Options: Nationwide offers a diverse range of coverage options tailored to the needs of Toyota Highlander drivers, providing flexibility and comprehensive protection.
• Discount Programs: Discounts for bundling policies and maintaining a clean driving record can help lower overall premiums for Toyota Highlander drivers.
• Positive Feedback for Claims: In our Nationwide car insurance review, learn how generally favorable reviews for claims satisfaction can benefit Toyota Highlander drivers.

Cons

• Limited State Availability: Nationwide’s insurance services are not available in all states, which may restrict access for some Toyota Highlander owners.
• Higher Premium Costs: Premiums might be higher for drivers with a less-than-perfect driving record, affecting affordability for Toyota Highlander insurance.

#9 – Liberty Mutual: Best for Coverage Options

Pros

• Customizable Insurance Policies: Liberty Mutual offers flexible insurance policies that can be tailored to meet the specific needs of Toyota Highlander drivers, providing personalized coverage options.
• Discounts and Savings Opportunities: View our Liberty Mutual car insurance review to discover how various discounts for safe driving and policy bundling can help Toyota Highlander drivers save.
• Extensive Local Agent Network: A wide network of local agents provides Toyota Highlander owners with tailored guidance and efficient policy management.

Cons

• Higher Premiums: Toyota Highlander drivers may find Liberty Mutual’s premiums to be higher compared to some competitors.
• Inconsistent Claims Handling: Feedback on claims processing can be mixed, with some Toyota Highlander owners reporting less satisfactory service.

Free Car Insurance Comparison

Enter your ZIP code below to view companies that have cheap car insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

#10 – Progressive: Best for Innovative Tools

Pros

• Competitive Premium Pricing: Progressive is known for offering competitive premiums along with various discount opportunities, making it an attractive option for Toyota Highlander owners.
• Advanced Digital Tools: Progressive’s sophisticated digital platform enhances policy management and claims filing, providing a better experience for Toyota Highlander drivers.
• Wide Range of Coverage Options: Delve into our Progressive car insurance review to explore the variety of coverage options and add-ons suited to Toyota Highlander drivers.

Cons

• Customer Service Issues: Some customers report less satisfactory experiences with Progressive’s customer service, which could affect the overall insurance experience for Toyota Highlander owners.
• Fluctuating Premiums: Premium rates can vary based on driving history and location, potentially leading to inconsistent costs for Toyota Highlander insurance.

Best Rates for Toyota Highlander Car Insurance

With various providers offering different rates and benefits, it’s essential to compare options to find the best fit for your needs. Considering the monthly rates for best Toyota Highlander car insurance, the cost can vary significantly depending on the provider and the level of coverage you choose.

Here’s a breakdown of the rates by coverage level and provider:

Toyota Highlander Car Insurance Monthly Rates by Provider & Coverage Level

When assessing car insurance for the Toyota Highlander, Geico stands out for its competitive pricing. While USAA offers the best rates overall, particularly for military families with excellent claims handling and tailored services, Erie remains a strong contender with slightly higher but still affordable rates.

For those seeking a blend of affordability and coverage, State Farm and Progressive offer valuable alternatives. State Farm delivers extensive coverage options, while Progressive provides a near-equivalent solution.

Evaluate each provider’s benefits and pricing to make an informed decision that best suits your insurance needs. To do this effectively, compare car insurance by coverage type.

Overview of Toyota Highlander Insurance Cost

When considering the cost for the best Toyota Highlander car insurance. Insurance rates can vary significantly based on several factors, including the level of deductibles and the driver’s profile. The following table provides a snapshot of average insurance rate:

Toyota Highlander Car Insurance Monthly Rates by Driver Profile

Choosing a lower car insurance deductible will increase your monthly premium but can reduce out-of-pocket costs if you need to file a claim. Additionally, drivers classified as high risk or those with teen drivers typically face higher premiums due to the increased likelihood of claims and accidents.

For insuring your Toyota Highlander, Geico, Erie, and USAA are top choices. Geico offers competitive rates and numerous discounts, coupled with excellent online tools and customer service. By evaluating your options carefully, you can find the best coverage that balances affordability with comprehensive protection, considering the average insurance cost for Toyota Highlander.

Free Car Insurance Comparison

Enter your ZIP code below to view companies that have cheap car insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

What Impacts the Cost of Toyota Highlander Insurance?

Toyota Highlander insurance costs are affected by the vehicle’s age, trim level, and model, with newer and higher trims usually costing more. Driver age, location, and driving record also influence premiums, with younger drivers and those with poor records typically facing higher rates.

Age of the Vehicle

When considering insurance for a Toyota Highlander, the vehicle’s age can significantly influence the cost of premiums. Typically, older Highlander models are less expensive to insure compared to their newer counterparts.

This trend arises because the value of older vehicles is lower, which in turn reduces the cost of comprehensive and collision coverage. The table below provides a detailed comparison of insurance premiums for various Toyota Highlander models,

Driver Age

Driver age can greatly influence the cost of insuring a Toyota Highlander. Car insurance rates for young drivers with points are typically higher compared to their older counterparts. Younger drivers often face elevated premiums because insurance companies consider them to be higher risk due to their limited driving experience and statistically higher accident rates.

As drivers mature and gain more experience, their premiums usually decrease. The table below provides a clear comparison of Toyota Highlander insurance rates across different age groups:

Toyota Highlander Car Insurance Monthly Rates by Age

As shown, insurance costs drop with age, with the greatest savings for drivers in their 50s and 60s. For the best coverage, consider Geico for competitive rates and discounts, Progressive for flexible options, and USAA for outstanding service and benefits for military families.

Comparing these providers you can find the most suitable and cost-effective insurance coverage for your age.

Driver Location

Your location can greatly affect the cost of insuring a Toyota Highlander. Insurance premiums vary depending on factors such as local traffic patterns, regional risk factors, and state regulations.

For instance, residents of high-density urban areas with higher accident rates or states with the highest vehicle theft rates might face higher insurance costs compared to those living in smaller towns or rural areas. The table shows how insurance rates can fluctuate based on location:

Toyota Highlander Car Insurance Monthly Rates by City

For the best coverage, consider Geico for its competitive rates and discounts, Progressive for its customizable options and Name Your Price tool, and USAA for its excellent service and benefits for military families. Comparing these providers can help you find the most affordable and suitable insurance based on your location.

Your Driving Record

driving record is a crucial factor in determining the cost of insuring a Toyota Highlander. Drivers with a clean record typically enjoy lower insurance premiums, while those with violations or accidents often face higher rates.

This impact is particularly pronounced for younger drivers, who are often penalized more heavily for driving infractions due to their higher risk profile. The table shows how insurance costs rise with driving record issues:

Toyota Highlander Car Insurance Insurance Monthly Rates by Age & Driving Record

providers like Geico, Progressive, and USAA. Geico is praised for its extensive range of discounts and competitive rates, Progressive offers valuable features like the Name Your Price tool and a variety of coverage options, and USAA is known for its exceptional customer service.

Evaluating these providers and maintaining a clean driving record can help you find the best insurance coverage at the most favorable rates. For additional details, explore our comprehensive resource titled “Best Car Insurance for a Bad Driving Record.”

Utilizing Discounts for Best Toyota Highlander Car Insurance

Seeking the best Toyota Highlander car insurance, utilizing available discounts can notably reduce your premiums. Various insurance companies offer different discounts to help you save money. Here’s an overview of the discounts offered by the top providers:

Geico offers savings for Anti-Theft devices, Good Student status, and multi-policy bundling. Progressive provides discounts for online quotes and paying in full. USAA offers military-specific discounts and savings for vehicle safety features.

Liberty Mutual rewards Accident-Free records and good students, while State Farm offers discounts for safe driving and bundling policies. Each provider offers distinct benefits to help reduce your insurance costs. Here are some effective ways to secure discounts and lower your insurance premiums.

• Bundle Policies: Combine auto insurance with other policies (e.g., home or renters) to receive a multi-policy discount.
• Maintain a Clean Driving Record: Avoid accidents and traffic violations to qualify for safe driver discounts.
• Good Student Discounts: Provide proof of good academic performance to earn discounts, especially for young drivers.
• Pay in Full: Opt to pay your premium in one lump sum rather than monthly to receive a pay-in-full discount on your car insurance payment methods.

By leveraging these discount opportunities and selecting the right provider, you can significantly reduce the cost of insuring your Toyota Highlander while ensuring you get the best coverage.

Are Toyota Highlanders Expensive to Insure?

Evaluating the best Toyota Highlander car insurance, it’s crucial to compare its insurance rates with those of similar SUVs. This comparison helps determine whether the Highlander offers a good balance of coverage and cost compared to other vehicles like the GMC Yukon XL, Mitsubishi Outlander Sport, and BMW X3.

Here’s a look at the insurance costs for the Toyota Highlander versus other popular SUVs:

Toyota Highlander Car Insurance Monthly Rates vs. Other Cars by Coverage Type

The Toyota Highlander has moderate insurance costs compared to other SUVs, being cheaper to insure than the BMW X3 but more expensive than the Mitsubishi Outlander Sport.

Providers like Geico are known for competitive rates and discounts, especially for safe drivers. Progressive offers customizable coverage and savings through policy bundling, while USAA delivers exceptional benefits, particularly for military families.

Choosing a provider that matches these competitive rates and discounts can help you secure comprehensive coverage for your Toyota Highlander and manage your insurance budget effectively. To learn more, explore our comprehensive resource on insurance titled “What is the difference between car make vs. model?”

Free Car Insurance Comparison

Enter your ZIP code below to view companies that have cheap car insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

Toyota Highlander Safety Ratings

Reviewing the best Toyota Highlander car insurance, the vehicle’s safety ratings play a crucial role in influencing your premiums. The Toyota Highlander’s strong safety performance can lead to lower insurance costs, as higher safety ratings often result in a lower risk assessment from insurers.

Understanding these factors is one of the different ways to lower car insurance rates for your Toyota Highlander. The following table outlines the Toyota Highlander’s performance in key safety tests, reflecting its strong safety credentials:

Toyota Highlander Safety Ratings

The Toyota Highlander’s high ratings across various safety tests—such as small and moderate overlap impacts, side impacts, roof strength, and head restraints—demonstrate its comprehensive safety features.

For the best Toyota Highlander car insurance, consider providers like Geico, which offers competitive rates and discounts for high safety ratings, and USAA, known for exceptional service and benefits tailored to vehicles with strong safety records.

Understanding how the Highlander’s safety performance affects insurance costs can help you make more informed decisions about your coverage.

Toyota Highlander Crash Test for

Good crash test ratings not only ensure that you are better protected in the event of a collision but also contribute to lower auto insurance rates for your Toyota Highlander.

Insurers consider these ratings to assess the safety and risk associated with covering your vehicle, which can directly impact your insurance premiums. Here’s a breakdown of the Toyota Highlander’s crash test performance:

Toyota Highlander Crash Test Ratings by Model Year

The Toyota Highlander consistently receives top ratings across various crash tests, including frontal and side impacts, as well as rollover tests. These high ratings indicate that the Highlander offers exceptional protection in collisions, which can lead to lower insurance costs.

Geico and USAA stand out. Geico offers competitive rates for vehicles with high safety ratings and provides discounts for robust crash test performance. USAA is renowned for its exceptional service and tailored discounts for vehicles with excellent safety features, especially benefiting military families.

Selecting an insurer that values these strong crash test ratings, you can enjoy comprehensive coverage at potentially reduced rates, ensuring both safety and savings for your Toyota Highlander. To delve deeper, refer to our in-depth report titled “Understanding Car Accidents.”

Toyota Highlander Insurance Loss Probability

The insurance loss probability of the Toyota Highlander plays a significant role in determining your insurance rates. The loss ratio reflects how frequently claims are made for different types of coverage, influencing the cost of your premiums.

Lower loss ratios typically translate to lower insurance rates due to reduced risk. Here’s a summary of the loss ratios for various insurance coverage categories for the Toyota Highlander:

Toyota Highlander car Insurance Loss Probability by Coverage Type

The Bodily Injury and Medical Payment categories have the lowest loss rates, suggesting fewer claims and potential for cost savings. Coverage types like Collision and Property Damage also reflect favorable loss rates, which can contribute to reduced insurance costs.

For the best Toyota Highlander car insurance, choose providers that recognize low loss ratios. Erie offers competitive rates and various discounts, Allstate provides savings through multi-policy bundling and good driver discounts, and Liberty Mutual rewards safe driving with accident-free discounts.

Choosing an insurance provider that recognizes the Toyota Highlander’s low loss ratios can lead to comprehensive coverage at reduced rates, helping you get the best insurance value for your vehicle. To expand your knowledge, refer to our comprehensive handbook titled “Compare Personal Liability and Property Damage (PLPD) Car Insurance.”

Free Car Insurance Comparison

Enter your ZIP code below to view companies that have cheap car insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

Top Toyota Highlander Insurance Companies

When deciding on car insurance for your Toyota Highlander, it’s crucial to find a provider that offers both value and coverage tailored to your needs. The following tables highlight the leading car insurance companies, showcasing their market share and volume to give you a clearer picture of your options:

Top Toyota Highlander Car Insurance Providers by Market Share

Geico stands out as an excellent choice, especially for those seeking a blend of affordability and convenience. Progressive attracts Highlander drivers with flexible coverage options and safe driver car insurance discounts.

USAA is ideal for military families, offering specialized benefits and exceptional service, while Chubb caters to those who prefer premium protection. Farmers and Nationwide also provide reliable options, with customizable coverage and attractive discount programs.

By reviewing the top Toyota Highlander insurance company, you can make an informed decision based on coverage, discounts, and customer service.

Get the Right Insurance for your Toyota Highlander

For the best Toyota Highlander car insurance, a variety of providers offering different benefits and features, is essential. Find an insurance plan that aligns with your needs and preferences, consider providers like Geico, Erie, and USAA.

Geico is highly regarded for its competitive rates and strong customer service, making it a popular choice for many drivers. Erie Insurance also offers a compelling option with its extensive coverage choices and high customer satisfaction, providing peace of mind through robust protection and a reputation for excellent service.

USAA stands out for its exceptional benefits tailored to military families, including superior claims handling and specialized coverage, making it a top choice for those who qualify. Thoroughly evaluating different insurance options and their benefits, including insurance for Toyota Highlander, can help you select a policy that offers comprehensive protection and value.

This ensures your Toyota Highlander is well-protected and your peace of mind is intact. Remember, the right insurance not only safeguards your vehicle but also enhances your overall driving experience. To gain profound insights, consult our extensive guide titled “Understanding Your Car Insurance Policy”

Ready to shop around for the best car insurance company? Enter your ZIP code below and see which one offers the coverage you need.

Free Car Insurance Comparison

Enter your ZIP code below to view companies that have cheap car insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption