Best Smart Fortwo Car Insurance in 2024 (Check Out the Top 10 Companies)

Top Pick for Smart Fortwo: State Farm

17,757 reviews

4.1

Company Facts

Full Coverage for Smart Fortwo

$141/mo

A.M. Best Rating

B (Fair)

Complaint Level

Low

Pros & Cons

• Has the third-lowest average premium among the top 10 providers
• Consistently strong financial standing and solid rankings
• Policies are available in all 50 states
• Customers have a variety of online options and an easy-to-use app

• Rates can be pricey depending on where you live
• Could stand to offer more discounts, like federal employees, green vehicles, and occupational
• Limited add-ons available

» State Farm Car Insurance Review

17,757 reviews

Compare Rates →

Best 24/7 Support for Smart Fortwo: Erie

1,814 reviews

4.3

Company Facts

Full Coverage for Lincoln Navigator

$177/mo

A.M. Best Rating

A+

Complaint Level

High

Pros & Cons

• Excellent claims service
• Affordable rates for good drivers
• Special coverage perks and add-on options
• A lock-in option for coverage rates

• Lack of availability in most states
• A higher-than-average number of customer complaints

» Erie Car Insurance Review

1,814 reviews

Compare Rates →

Best Custom Plan for Smart Fortwo: Geico

19,116 reviews

4.1

Company Facts

Full Coverage for Lincoln Navigator

$216/mo

A.M. Best Rating

A++

Complaint Level

Low

Pros & Cons

• Affordable rates
• A++ rating from A.M. Best
• Good claims handling

• Doesn’t have gap insurance
• Few in-person agents

» Geico Car Insurance Review

19,116 reviews

Compare Rates →

Leading choices for insuring best Smart Fortwo car insurance are State Farm, Erie and Geico, with rates starting at just $40 per month.

Remember that car insurance is a business based on a certain risk-to-reward ratio. In other words, your car insurance company is rewarded by profits when it invests the money from your premiums in a number of financial vehicles.

Our Top 10 Company Picks: Best Smart Fortwo Car Insurance

Company	Rank	Multi-Vehicle Discount	A.M. Best	Best For	Jump to Pros/Cons
	#1	8%	B	Many Discounts	State Farm
	#2	15%	A+	24/7 Support	Erie
	#3	10%	A++	Custom Plan	Geico
	#4	12%	A	Local Agents	Farmers
	#5	14%	A+	Add-on Coverages	Allstate
	#6	11%	A	Online App	AAA
	#7	18%	A+	Innovative Programs	Progressive
	#8	9%	A+	Usage Discount	Nationwide
	#9	7%	A	Customizable Polices	Liberty Mutual
	#10	13%	A++	Military Savings	USAA

At the same time, the company risks losing all of your premium money, plus the profit it has earned if an accident should ever cause you have filling car insurance claim.

Now gives you instant access to the best online car insurance quotes! Entering your ZIP code.

#1 – State Farm: Top Overall Pick

Pros

• Exceptional Customer Service: State Farm is renowned for its superior customer support and efficient claims processing. They consistently receive high ratings for handling inquiries and claims smoothly.
• Diverse Coverage Options: Offers a broad selection of coverage plans, including liability, collision, and comprehensive, which makes it a versatile choice for the best Smart Fortwo car insurance.
• Nationwide Availability: Accessible across all states, making it a convenient option for many seeking the best Smart Fortwo car insurance. Read more in our “State Farm Car Insurance Review.”

Cons

• Potentially Higher Premiums: Rates might be more expensive compared to some competitors, especially in urban areas where the risk is higher.
• Basic Digital Tools: Their online and app features are less advanced compared to some insurers, which may affect the convenience of managing your policy.

#2 – Erie: Best for 24/7 Support

Pros

• 24/7 Support: Erie provides continuous customer service, available day and night for claims and support. This is ideal for ensuring you get help whenever needed with the best Smart Fortwo car insurance.
• Cost-Effective Premiums: Known for offering competitive rates, Erie’s premiums are often lower, making it a budget-friendly choice for Smart Fortwo insurance.
• Comprehensive Coverage: Provides a range of insurance options, including roadside assistance, which can enhance your coverage for the Smart Fortwo. Read it more in Erie car insurance review.

Cons

• Regional Limitations: Erie’s availability is limited to certain states, which might be a drawback if you relocate to a state where they don’t operate.
• Mixed Online Reviews: Some customers have reported issues with online claims processing, which could be a concern for those who prefer digital management.

#3 – Geico: Best for Custom Plan

Pros

• Affordable Premiums: Known for its low-cost insurance, Geico’s competitive rates are attractive for those looking to insure their Smart Fortwo without breaking the bank.
• Advanced Digital Tools: Features a robust app and online platform for managing your policy, making it easy to handle all aspects of your Smart Fortwo insurance, which you can learn about in our “Geico Car Insurance Review.”
• Financial Stability: Geico has strong ratings for financial stability, ensuring reliability in handling your claims and coverage.

Cons

• Variable Customer Service: Customer service quality can vary by location, which might impact your experience with the best Smart Fortwo car insurance.
• Limited Local Agent Access: Fewer options for face-to-face interactions with agents could be a downside for those who prefer personalized assistance.

#4 – Farmers: Best for Local Agents

Pros

• Local Agent Network: Farmers has a vast network of local agents who offer personalized service, which can be beneficial for obtaining the best Smart Fortwo car insurance tailored to your needs.
• Reputable Claims Support: Known for effectively managing claims, Farmers ensures a smooth process if you need to file a claim.  Find out more in our “Farmers Car Insurance Review.”
• Educational Resources: Offers valuable resources and advice, which can help you understand and optimize your coverage for the Smart Fortwo.

Cons

• Higher Premiums: Insurance rates may be higher compared to some other providers, potentially making it less affordable for some customers.
• Discount Variability: Availability of discounts can differ based on your location, affecting how much you can save on the best Smart Fortwo car insurance.

#5 – Allstate: Best for Add-on Coverages

Pros

• User-Friendly App: Features a well-designed app and online portal that makes managing your insurance easy and efficient. Learn more in our “Allstate Car Insurance Review.”
• Local Agent Network: Availability of local agents for personalized support can help tailor your Smart Fortwo coverage to your specific needs.
• Comprehensive Insurance Options: Allstate offers a wide range of insurance products beyond auto, providing a one-stop solution for all your insurance needs.

Cons

• Higher Premiums: Rates can be higher compared to some competitors, which might be a drawback if you’re looking for the most cost-effective Smart Fortwo insurance.
• Customer Service Issues: Some customers have reported mixed experiences with claims and customer service, which could impact your satisfaction.

#6 – AAA: Best for Online App

Pros

• Roadside Assistance: Renowned for its top-notch roadside assistance services, which can be a significant advantage for Smart Fortwo drivers.
• Member Discounts: Provides exclusive discounts to AAA members, making it an attractive option for those who are already members. Read it more on AAA car insurance review.
• Strong Reputation: Known for high customer satisfaction and a solid overall reputation in the insurance industry.

Cons

• Membership Requirements: Insurance is often limited to AAA members, which might not be ideal for those outside the AAA network.
• Potentially Higher Rates: Premiums may be higher for non-members compared to other insurance providers, which could affect affordability.

#7 – Progressive: Best for Innovative Programs

Pros

• Innovative Programs: Offers unique programs like Snapshots, which rewards safe drawing habits and can potentially lower your Smart Fortwo insurance rates.
• Advanced Online Tools: Features a user-friendly app and online tools for easy policy management and quote comparisons.
• Flexible Payment Plans: Provides various payment options, allowing you to choose a plan that fits your budget. For a complete list, read our “Progressive Car Insurance Review.”

Cons

• Inconsistent Customer Service: Quality of customer service can vary based on location, potentially affecting your experience with the best Smart Fortwo car insurance.
• Policy Complexity: The range of options and add-ons might be overwhelming for some, making it difficult to choose the right coverage.

#8 – Nationwide: Best for Usage Discount

Pros

• Comprehensive Coverage Options: Includes a range of coverage plans and benefits, such as new car replacement and accident forgiveness.
• Strong Financial Ratings: Known for high financial stability ratings, ensuring reliable coverage and claims handling.
• Good Customer Support: Generally, receives positive feedback for customer service and support, which you can read more about in our “Review of Allstate vs. Nationwide.”

Cons

• Discount Availability: Discounts and benefits might vary depending on your location, which could impact your savings on Smart Fortwo insurance.
• Higher Premiums for Some: Rates may be higher for certain drivers, affecting affordability for those seeking the best Smart Fortwo car insurance.

#9 – Liberty Mutual: Best for Customizable Polices

Pros

• Competitive Rates: Known for offering competitive pricing and various discount options to make insurance more affordable, which you can check out in our “Liberty Mutual Car Insurance Review.”
• Advanced Digital Tools: Features a robust app and online portal for managing your policy efficiently.
• Good Customer Feedback: Generally, receives positive reviews for customer service and support.

Cons

• Fluctuating Premiums: Insurance rates can vary based on location and driving history, potentially affecting overall cost.
• Regional Variability: Availability and service quality may differ by region, impacting your experience with Smart Fortwo insurance.

#10 – USAA: Best for Military Savings

Pros

• Exclusive Military Discounts: Offers substantial discounts for military members and their families, making it a top choice for the best Smart Fortwo car insurance in this group.
• Outstanding Customer Service: Highly rated for customer satisfaction and claims handling, ensuring a positive experience, which is covered in our “USAA Car Insurance Review.”
• Comprehensive Coverage: Includes a range of coverage options and additional benefits tailored to the needs of military families.

Cons

• Eligibility Restrictions: Insurance is only available to military members, veterans, and their families, limiting access for others.
• Limited Non-Military Options: May not be the best choice for those outside the military community, as coverage and benefits are tailored specifically to this group.

Evaluating the Smart Fortwo

One of the biggest concerns of the Smart Fortwo in the U.S. market revolves around safety issues. The car did fairly well in its first round of crash tests, giving Smart USA a glimmer of hope that the car was safer than most critics claimed.

However, those tests were done using other cars of similar size and weight.

When the Fortwo was tested against larger cars, it did very poorly.

Because the car is so small and lightweight, the second round of testing revealed the possibility of significant injury to any occupants when involved in an accident with a larger vehicle.

The dashboard, steering wheel, and pedals posed significant risk to the driver to the point that fatalities became a real concern.

From an insurance perspective, the safety results tell car insurance companies that the risk posed by the Smart Fortwo is very high.

Coverage Options for the Smart Fortwo

Few auto insurance providers, if any, preclude Smart Fortwo owners from getting coverage. It is important to note that the Smart Fortwo is an Italian car, which means that this vehicle was debuted in Europe before it was sold in the U.S.

Therefore, car insurance companies in other countries might rate the Smart Fortwo differently than insurance providers based in the U.S.

When consumers first go to apply for car insurance quotes, they are asked to supply the vehicle’s make and model or vehicle identification number before they can proceed.

You would immediately known if a car insurance company does not offer insurance on the Smart Fortwo because you would not be able to get information on rates.

Some auto insurance providers specialize in providing best car insurance for Japanese imports, sports cars, or vehicles considered to be a high insurance risk.

Even if you happen to come across a company that does not extend coverage for the Smart Fortwo, you will probably find that this is the exception and not the rule.

In choosing coverage price may matter, it is better to get a car insurance that offers cheapest but best in the quality at the same time. Looking at State Farm, Erie and Geico, you may learn that top provider may help you to save more.

Enter your ZIP code now.

Qualities That Positively Affect Car Insurance Rates for the Smart Fortwo

In terms of collision vs comprehensive what is the difference, one of the things the Fortwo has going for it is that its repair and replacement costs would be relatively low.

Add to that the fact that these cars are still somewhat of a novelty, which keeps their Blue Book value high, and you have a scenario in which a car insurance company could consider the vehicle a total loss and still get by with a reasonable payout.

The car’s small size and light weight frame reduce the potential for property damage in some accidents.

A heavier, full-size sedan might cause significant property damage if it jumps the curb and ends up in someone’s yard, the Smart Fortwo is less likely to do such severe damage.

The Cost Comparison: Insuring a Smart Fortwo vs. Other Vehicles

According to the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety, the 2011 Smart Fortwo has an all around “good” safety rating. The crash and safety tests conducted showed that the Smart Fortwo stood up well during impact.

Smart cars can become significantly damaged during impact, especially when driven at high speeds.

Smart Fortwo drivers that do a lot of highway driving might be more at risk of being involved in dangerous accidents than those that live in more suburban settings.

Overall, Smart Fortwo owners likely get lower insurance quotes than the owners of larger vehicles because of the Fortwo’s size, price, and functionality. Insurance company that has a best offer for Smart Fortwo are State Farm, Erie and Geico. Enter your ZIP code now to begin comparing.