Allstate vs. Amica Car Insurance Comparison [2024]

Are you trying to decide between Allstate and Amica? These are both among the best car insurance companies within the U.S.

Allstate is the 2nd largest auto insurance provider, right after State Farm. Amica has had the highest customer satisfaction rating continuously for the past ten years.

For comparative purposes, here are some more facts and figures on Amica Mutual insurance company and Allstate to help make it easier to decide.

Also, be sure to enter your zip code above for a free car insurance comparison from multiple providers!

What makes Allstate one of the leading insurance companies?

Allstate is the biggest U.S. publicly held company that offers personal lines of insurance and financial products.

It has more than 17 million policyholders in the U.S. Allstate employs nearly 37,000 individuals and has over 14,000 agents.

Allstate’s famous slogan “You’re in good hands,” came out in 2004.

Allstate is also famous for its auto insurance discounts like accident forgiveness, though you shouldn’t count Amica out of the mix. If your car has a good safety rating or if it’s been in an accident recently, then you may be able to get some of those car discounts from Allstate as well.

If you’re looking for cheap car insurance rates, look no further than Allstate. They offer great coverage at affordable prices that are sure to fit into any budget. You can usually save money by just shopping around with insurance carriers.

Free Car Insurance Comparison

Enter your ZIP code below to view companies that have cheap car insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

What are Allstate insurance and financial products?

Allstate provides competitive rates for:

• Homeowners Insurance
• Auto Insurance coverage
• Life Insurance
• Retirement planning
• Annuities
• Mutual funds

Allstate offers a special safe driver discount on your auto insurance if you do not have any accidents or violations for 3 years and an additional discount if you maintain a clear record for 5 years.

How did Allstate get started?

In 1930, a friend of Robert E. Wood–the president of Sears, Roebuck and Company–suggested that Sears create an automobile insurance company and offer it through the mail.

By 1931, Allstate became a division of the company.

In 1993, Allstate separated from Sears, Roebuck and Company, and formed a publicly traded firm. By June of 1995, all of its financial ties to Sears were cut when Sears divested the rest of its shares to Sears stockholders.

To learn more about the company, check out our Allstate car insurance review.

Amica’s 100 Years Of Experience

In 1907, the Automobile Mutual Insurance Company of America (Amica) began offering auto insurance in Providence, Rhode Island.

The founder, A. T. Vigneron, based his company on selling to low risk drivers and paying dividends exclusively to the policyholders.

Amica was able to increase its number of policyholders and pay out dividends on most policies during the market crash of 1929.

Today, Amica has 3,000 employees and provides insurance in 39 states across the country. It moved its headquarters from Providence to Lincoln, Rhode Island in 1994 to a bigger office complex.

Read more:

• Amica vs. Nationwide Car Insurance Comparison
• Amica vs. Progressive Car Insurance Comparison
• Amica vs. The Hartford Car Insurance Comparison
• 21st Century vs. Amica Car Insurance Comparison

Free Car Insurance Comparison

Enter your ZIP code below to view companies that have cheap car insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

What Does Amica Sell?

Amica offers investment and insurance products including:

• Marine
• Automobile
• Life
• Personal liability umbrella
• Basic home insurance and renters insurance policy
• Flood insurance
• Annuities
• Retirement plans

Here’s how you can get an Amica Mutual car insurance quote online.

How do customers rate Allstate and Amica?

Each year J.D. Power performs a “National Homeowners Insurance Study” and a “National Auto Insurance Study.”

This research asks thousands of consumers about how satisfied they are with their insurance provider.

A scale of 1 to 5 is used. One means less than “the rest” of the other companies and 5 means “among the best.” Here are the results for both companies.

“2009 National Homeowner’s Insurance Study”

1. Customer Overall experience – Allstate 3, Amica 5
2. Prices – Allstate 3, Amica 5
3. Policies offered – Allstate 3, Amica 5
4. Contacting Insured – Allstate 3, Amica 5
5. Payment and billing – Allstate 3, Amica 5

Free Car Insurance Comparison

Enter your ZIP code below to view companies that have cheap car insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

“2009 National Auto Insurance Study”

1. Customer Overall experience – Allstate 3, Amica 5
2. Prices – Allstate 2, Amica 5
3. Policies offered – Allstate 3, Amica 5
4. Contacting Insured – Allstate 3, Amica 5
5. Payment and billing – Allstate 3, Amica 5

How do Allstate vs Amica stack up?

So, should you buy your car insurance from the insurance carriers Amica insurance or Allstate?

Here are some things to consider before making this decision:

The cost of premiums will be higher if you choose Amica over Allstate. This may not seem like much but it adds up quickly. If you want to save money then go with Allstate.

You can get car insurance discounts by choosing Allstate instead of Amica. These discounts include:

• Discounts at local businesses

• Discounts at restaurants

Both companies have their strong and weak points, so it’s always a good idea to check around and compare multiple insurance quotes.

Well, the decision is up to you, because everyone’s situation is different. But be sure to do your research and compare quotes from many different companies before buying.

Enter your zip code to get started comparing quotes from mutiple providers today!

Free Car Insurance Comparison

Enter your ZIP code below to view companies that have cheap car insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption